Don't Go Baking My Heart Bakery

Hi, I'm Caitlin!

Hi there- I am Caitlin Carr, a 16 year old high school student based in Califon/Tewksbury, NJ, and I have been baking for years. I create everything from the most delicious cookies and cupcakes of the finest quality to celebration and wedding cakes! I make top-quality, handmade desserts for every occasion- and would love to provide the delicious finishing touch to your event!

What I Offer

Sugar Cookies

I offer gorgeous sugar cookies hand decorated- they look just as amazing as they taste!


I have cupcakes to satisfy whatever you may fancy, whether just a treat at home or a party of 100!


Cakes big and small, simple and grand, you can have it all to compliment and elevate your celebration.

Recent Customer Reviews!

Jee C.

"Your cake was beyond delicious and so so beautiful!! I plan of being a customer of Don't Go Baking My Heart Bakery going forward and will even pick up - I am willing to travel for food!"


"The cookies were such a bit hit at our party!!! Everyone thought they looked and tasted amazing 😍. Thank you again for doing such a great job!!"

Stacey R.

"The cakes were a hit as always! You have wonderful talent!!"

We Offer Substitutions for Dietary Restrictions and Allergies!

I can create the perfect cake for you, even if that cake is gluten-free or dairy-free. This will not increase the price of your order- just answer that on an order form or voice your concerns!